The Minnesota Twins still need to sign a shortstop this offseason, but that won’t happen for a long time with the MLB Lockout. Jorge Polanco could play there if need be, but if he and the organization want long-term success, they’ll keep him at second base.

Since making his debut in 2014, Polanco has primarily played shortstop. It wasn’t until last year had he made the shift to second. The decision to sign Andrelton Simmons wasn’t all that bad because it showed Twins Territory that Polanco should be the long-term second baseman.

After having an MVP caliber season in 2019, Polanco has struggled with injuries. However, because he made the transition to second, he was able to suit up in 152 games and stay relatively healthy.

Polanco was an average-at-best defender at short. It’s also a demanding position, and he’s had a history of injuries, specifically his ankle.

Last year he hit .269, with 33 home runs and 98 runs batted in. His batting average was the second-lowest of his career, but that doesn’t tell the full story. He finished with the highest slugging percentage of his career and third-best on-base percentage.

When Polanco has struggled with an ankle injury, we’ve seen him lose his power. A large part of his success at the plate has come from his ability to drive the ball. There are countless games in which he’s hit clutch home runs.

Polanco also had a career year defensively at second base. From 2016-2019 (2020 not included – shortened season), his fielding percentage ranged anywhere from .864-.964.

In 2021, he finished with a fielding percentage of .974. Polanco committed 22 errors in 2019 but reduced that number to 12 last season. Granted, second is an easier position, but that’s a drastic improvement.

For this plan to work, Minnesota must sign a shortstop in free agency. Maybe Jose Miranda could play short? Nick Gordon as well, but he’s better suited in a super-utility role. This all comes down to what the front office does after the lockout.

The Twins should keep Polanco at second because it allows him to play better and stay healthy. When those two things are clicking, Minnesota is a much better ballclub.